Agency vs. Dermatica Comparison [2026]: Which Anti-Aging and Melasma Treatment Is Better?

Last updated: October 21, 2026 Reviewed by PrescribedGlow Editorial Team, Editorial

Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Our editorial opinions are our own.

Agency

★★★☆
Check Agency
VS

Dermatica

★★★★
Check Dermatica
Our Pick: Agency

Agency is the practical choice for new patients because Dermatica is permanently closing its US business on December 16, 2026 and has already stopped accepting new US subscribers. On the merits, Dermatica combined tretinoin and 4% hydroquinone into a single customized cream for $29.95 per month (or $22.42/month prepaid), while Agency splits anti-aging and pigment correction into two formulas — a four-ingredient Future Formula with dexpanthenol, and a Dark Spot Formula that can include hydroquinone up to 12% — costing up to $65 per month when bundled.

Editor’s update (October 2026): Dermatica confirmed it will permanently close its US business on December 16, 2026, and is no longer accepting new US subscribers (per Dermatica’s own announcement, reported by Cosmetics Business). Current Dermatica patients should plan their transition before that date. New patients should sign up with Agency instead.

What is the difference between Agency and Dermatica?

The primary difference between Agency and Dermatica is how they structure their prescription regimens and pricing. Agency divides anti-aging and pigment correction into two separate four-ingredient products—the Future Formula and the Dark Spot Formula—costing up to $65 monthly combined. Dermatica compounds anti-aging, melasma, acne, or rosacea actives into one bottle for $29.95 per month.

Both platforms operate as asynchronous store-and-forward teledermatology clinics. Patients complete an online medical intake and upload facial photographs, which a licensed clinician reviews within 24 to 48 hours. A systematic review of 40 clinical studies published in the Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare (Mounessa et al., 2018; PMID: 28350281) found that 96% of studies evaluating store-and-forward teledermatology reported high patient satisfaction due to convenience and diagnostic concordance with in-office visits.

While Agency—founded by Curology’s creators—focuses exclusively on mature skin concerns like anti-aging and hyperpigmentation, Dermatica functions as a broader dermatology clinic. In addition to photoaging and dark spots, Dermatica compounds specialized prescription treatments for acne and papulopustular rosacea, including topical ivermectin and metronidazole.

Which is better for anti-aging and melasma: Agency or Dermatica?

Dermatica could compound 4% hydroquinone and tretinoin into one nightly formula at no extra charge, but it is closing to new US patients. For new patients today, Agency is the only option — it pairs micro-dosed tretinoin with barrier-supporting dexpanthenol and niacinamide in its Future Formula, and offers a Dark Spot Formula with hydroquinone up to 12% for melasma.

Melasma is a chronic pigmentation disorder affecting an estimated 5 million individuals in the United States (Desai et al., Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, 2024; PMID: 37748556). According to the Cleveland Clinic, roughly 90% of people who develop melasma are women. In a 12-week double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of 48 melasma patients published in the Journal of Dermatological Treatment (Ennes et al., 2000; PMID: 11140927), 4% hydroquinone achieved partial or total pigment clearance in 95% of treated patients (37.5% total clearance and 57.5% partial clearance).

With Dermatica, a provider could blend 4% hydroquinone directly with tretinoin to address dark spots and fine lines in one step, but Dermatica is no longer accepting new US patients. With Agency, tretinoin is housed in the Future Formula ($40/month), while hydroquinone — available up to 12%, higher than Dermatica’s 4% — is restricted to the separate Dark Spot Formula ($35/month). For a closer look at higher-strength options, see our Agency vs. Musely comparison and Musely vs. Dermatica comparison.

How much does Agency cost compared to Dermatica?

Dermatica was up to 54% cheaper than Agency depending on your regimen, charging $29.95 per month ($59.90 billed every 56 days) plus a one-time $4.99 prescribing fee, with prepaid plans dropping to $22.42 monthly — but these prices now apply only to existing Dermatica customers, since the company has stopped accepting new US subscribers ahead of its December 16, 2026 shutdown. Agency charges $40 per month for its Future Formula, $35 for its Dark Spot Formula, or $65 monthly for both, and remains open to new patients.

A study published in Cutis (Rothstein et al., 2017; PMID: 29360888) found that the average out-of-pocket cost for a single in-office dermatology visit for uninsured patients is $221 before pharmacy expenses. Both telehealth subscriptions reduce this barrier and qualify for HSA and FSA reimbursement.

Feature & Pricing Tier Agency Dermatica
Anti-Aging Monthly Cost $40.00/mo ($80.00 every 60 days) $29.95/mo ($59.90 every 56 days)
Dark Spot Monthly Cost $35.00/mo ($70.00 every 60 days) $29.95/mo ($59.90 every 56 days)
Combined Anti-Aging + Dark Spot $65.00/mo ($130.00 Duo every 60 days) $29.95/mo (combined in 1 bottle)
Multi-Month Prepaid Plans None 4-Mo ($25.25/mo), 6-Mo ($23.83/mo), 12-Mo ($22.42/mo)
Initial Prescribing Fee $0.00 $4.99 one-time fee
Tretinoin & Hydroquinone Range 0.009%–0.1% tretinoin; up to 12% hydroquinone (Dark Spot Formula) 0.015%–0.1% tretinoin; up to 4% hydroquinone
Accepting New US Signups? Yes No — closes permanently December 16, 2026

For existing Dermatica subscribers, Dermatica saves $120 per year over Agency on a single anti-aging formula, or over $420 annually versus requiring both tretinoin and hydroquinone — but new patients can no longer access these Dermatica prices, since the company has stopped taking new US signups ahead of its December 16, 2026 closure.

How do Agency and Dermatica prescription ingredients compare?

Both platforms center their anti-aging regimens on topical tretinoin. For hyperpigmentation, Dermatica compounded hydroquinone up to 4% alongside azelaic acid and tranexamic acid, while Agency’s Dark Spot Formula can go up to 12% hydroquinone. Agency differentiates itself by compounding four active ingredients per bottle—adding soothing dexpanthenol, kojic acid, or antioxidant resveratrol—while Dermatica offered broader clinical actives including adapalene, clindamycin, ivermectin, and metronidazole.

In a 2-year randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of 204 subjects published in the American Journal of Clinical Dermatology (Kang et al., 2005; PMID: 16060712), daily application of 0.05% tretinoin emollient cream produced statistically significant reductions in fine wrinkling, coarse wrinkling, and mottled facial hyperpigmentation throughout 24 months.

  • Agency Formulas: The Future Formula combines tretinoin (0.009% to 0.1%) with azelaic acid, tranexamic acid, niacinamide, and hydrating dexpanthenol to cushion the skin barrier during the tretinoin beginner adjustment phase. The Dark Spot Formula blends up to 12% hydroquinone with kojic acid, azelaic acid, and hydrocortisone.
  • Dermatica Formulas: Dermatica starts tretinoin around 0.015% and scales up to 0.1%, blending it with 4% niacinamide, azelaic acid, or 4% hydroquinone. Both brands require cycling off hydroquinone every three to four months to prevent exogenous ochronosis.

Can you switch between Agency and Dermatica easily?

Switching from Agency to Dermatica is no longer possible for new patients, since Dermatica has stopped accepting new US subscribers ahead of its December 16, 2026 closure. Existing Dermatica patients transitioning to Agency can do so easily, since both platforms allow online self-service cancellation. During your new online intake, share a photo or list the exact ingredient concentrations of your current bottle so your new clinician can match your tretinoin tolerance.

Neither platform refunds orders that have already entered pharmacy compounding. Cancel Agency via Manage Subscription at least 48 hours before your 60-day renewal date, or cancel Dermatica at least five working days before your 56-day dispatch date. Discontinue your old bottle before starting your new cream, as layering two prescription retinoids increases the risk of severe barrier disruption and irritant contact dermatitis. For more details on digital prescriptions, see our guide on how telehealth skincare works.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better for anti-aging: Agency or Dermatica? Dermatica offered a customizable single-cream anti-aging formula starting at $29.95 per month ($22.42 prepaid), but it is closing its US business on December 16, 2026 and no longer accepts new subscribers. For new patients, Agency is the only option, with a dedicated four-ingredient Future Formula ($40/month) featuring dexpanthenol and tranexamic acid with a structured step-up tretinoin titration schedule.

Which is better for melasma and dark spots: Agency or Dermatica? Dermatica was cost-effective for melasma because it compounded 4% hydroquinone and tretinoin into a single $29.95 monthly formula, but it has stopped accepting new US subscribers ahead of its December 16, 2026 closure. For new patients, Agency is the only option: it splits anti-aging tretinoin ($40/month) and a Dark Spot Formula that can include hydroquinone up to 12% ($35/month) into two separate bottles, costing $65 per month when bundled together.

How much does Agency cost compared to Dermatica? Dermatica cost $29.95 per month ($59.90 billed every 56 days) plus a one-time $4.99 prescribing fee, with prepaid plans dropping to $22.42 per month, but it is no longer accepting new US subscribers and will close permanently on December 16, 2026 — these prices now apply only to existing customers. Agency costs $40 per month for the Future Formula ($80 every 60 days) or $35 per month for the Dark Spot Formula, with no consultation fee, and remains open to new patients.

Do Agency and Dermatica both prescribe hydroquinone and tretinoin? Yes, both platforms prescribe custom compounded tretinoin (up to 0.1%). Dermatica compounds hydroquinone up to 4%, while Agency’s Dark Spot Formula can include hydroquinone up to 12%. Because prolonged hydroquinone usage carries a risk of exogenous ochronosis, medical providers on both platforms require patients to cycle off hydroquinone after three to four months and transition to non-hydroquinone brighteners.

Can you use Agency and Dermatica together? No, you should never use Agency and Dermatica prescription formulas at the same time. Both contain high-potency active ingredients like tretinoin, azelaic acid, and hydroquinone. Layering them will compromise your skin barrier, causing severe retinoid dermatitis, peeling, erythema, and rebound post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation.

How do you cancel Agency vs Dermatica subscriptions? Both services allow online cancellation through your account settings without phone calls. Agency requires you to cancel at least 48 hours before your 60-day renewal invoice is generated. Dermatica requires cancellation requests at least five working days before your next scheduled 56-day shipment dispatch date, though all existing Dermatica subscriptions end by December 16, 2026 regardless, when the company permanently closes its US operations.

Bottom line

Agency is the practical winner for new patients. Dermatica has permanently closed to new US signups ahead of its December 16, 2026 shutdown, so Agency — with its Future Formula for anti-aging and a Dark Spot Formula offering hydroquinone up to 12% for melasma — is the only one of the two most people can actually sign up for today.

Dermatica remains a strong option for existing subscribers through its closure date. At $29.95 per month (or $22.42 per month prepaid), it delivers clinical-strength tretinoin and 4% hydroquinone in a single customized bottle — but current patients should plan their transition to Agency or another provider before December 16, 2026.

Start your Agency consultation → · Read our full Agency review → · Read our full Dermatica review → · Compare Curology vs. Dermatica →


Sources

  1. Mounessa JS, Chapman S, Dellavalle RP, et al. A systematic review of satisfaction with teledermatology. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare. 2018;24(4):263-270. PMID: 28350281.
  2. Desai SR, Alexis AF, Elbuluk N, et al. Best practices in the treatment of melasma with a focus on patients with skin of color. Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology. 2024;90(2):269-279. PMID: 37748556.
  3. Cleveland Clinic. Melasma: Causes, Symptoms, Diagnosis & Treatment. Cleveland Clinic Health Library. https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/21454-melasma
  4. Ennes SBP, Paschoalick RC, Mota De Avelar Alchorne M. A double-blind, comparative, placebo-controlled study of the efficacy and tolerability of 4% hydroquinone as a depigmenting agent in melasma. Journal of Dermatological Treatment. 2000;11(3):173-179. PMID: 11140927.
  5. Rothstein B, Gonzalez J, et al. Direct and indirect patient costs of dermatology clinic visits and their impact on access to care and provider preference. Cutis. 2017;100(6):405-408. PMID: 29360888.
  6. Kang S, Bergfeld W, Gottlieb AB, et al. Long-term efficacy and safety of tretinoin emollient cream 0.05% in the treatment of photodamaged facial skin: a two-year, randomized, placebo-controlled study. American Journal of Clinical Dermatology. 2005;6(4):245-253. PMID: 16060712.
  7. Dermatica to permanently close US operations. Cosmetics Business, October 2026.
  8. Agency (by Curology). Dark Spot Rx hydroquinone concentration confirmed directly by Curology, Inc., October 2026.